Sometimes there’s a fine line between cultural appreciation and cultural appropriation. Fans continuously reached out to K-Pop idols and their agencies to discuss the difference, hoping to enact change. Although progress has been made, within the past two years some poor styling and marketing choices have still crossed into cultural appropriation territory, according to fans.
1. Jake’s necklace
CJ ENM and HYBE‘s music label BELIFT LAB is facing backlash for less than stellar styling. When ENHYPEN performed on Inkigayo, Jake wore this necklace.
The necklace has the name of Allah (God in Islam) written on it in Arabic. Since Jake is not Muslim, Muslim ENGENEs believe it was not appropriate for ENHYPEN’s stylists to include this jewelry as part of his look. To Muslims, “Allah” is a sacred word, not an accessory.
Why is jake from enhypen wearing a necklace that says Allah(god) on it😭 this is so disrespectful?????
ALLAHS NAME IS NOT AN ACCESSORY, RELIGION IS NOT AN ACCESSORY pic.twitter.com/yjtwHGhdJC
— Stayc (@megshottie_) January 29, 2022
2. The marketing for BTS’s “Artist-Made” Collection
BTS‘s Jungkook was the final member to release his “Artist-Made Collection,” merch designed by the members themselves. Although Jungkook was the brain behind his hoodie and mood lamp, he was not responsible for a divisive promotional photo.
ARTIST-MADE COLLECTION BY #BTS
Merch. Style Photo – Jung Kook ver.
— HYBE MERCH (@HYBE_MERCH) January 21, 2022
The above photo for Jungkook’s “MIKROKOSMOS MOOD LAMP” features an “indoor tent” that Indigenous ARMYs say is, in fact, a teepee (also known as tepee and tipi).
The floor of the tipi represents the earth on which we live, the walls represent the sky and the poles represent the trails that extend from the earth to the spirit world (Dakota teachings). Tipis hold special significance among many different nations and Aboriginal cultures across North America.
Fans pointed out that the appropriation of Indigenous culture has become so commonplace that many don’t recognize it when they see it.
very disappointed… again. honestly i feel defeated. most ARMY don't care about CA – especially when its CA of Indigenous ppls. so they won't even bat an eye or question this photo 😔. https://t.co/6j0oJ0de5i
— Ojistoh⁷ (H) (@BeadsTS) January 21, 2022
3. NCT U’s “Make A Wish (Birthday Song)” Promotions
SM Entertainment came under fire for marketing NCT U merchandise that appropriates Islamic culture, according to fans.
#SMStopDisrespectingIslam trended on Twitter shortly after new merch items for NCT U‘s song were unveiled. Some fans took issue with the merch’s mosque-like designs and an ornate cube that closely resembles a sacred place of worship: The Kaaba.
my tl is filled with people asking about the nct situation
this is their new merch as you can see they used the design of the mosque and that little cube thats the kaaba
for performance set they did this people spoke up but they did not do anything about it and now this pic.twitter.com/0y0z43Ya9l
— tete day🐻⁷ (@bngtnshahad) December 11, 2020
The set for NCT U’s “Make A Wish (Birthday Song)” MV also received backlash for resembling mosques.
4. LOONA’s “PTT (Paint the Town)” Styling
LOONA‘s “PTT (Paint the Town)” teaser became the subject of an appreciation vs appropriation debate. Some fans felt that two headpieces from the “&3” teaser appropriated Indian culture. One was worn by Hyunjin…
…and the other by Vivi.
These headpieces are similar to two traditional South Asian jewelry pieces: the maang tikka and matha patti.
Both headpieces have ties to Indian bridal traditions and Hinduism.
seem like a pretty pendant, it isn’t. matha pattis and maang tikkas hold a special meaning to desis, since they come from hinduism. in hinduism there are a few main centers of energy in our bodies, which we call the chakras. these chakras create a continuous flow of energy
— haseul thinker (@thinkshaseul) June 24, 2021
Some fans, however, felt BlockBerry Creative was showing appreciation for Indian culture. Prior to releasing the teaser, the company announced that “PTT (Paint the Town)” would have Bollywood (Hindi cinema) influences.
5. OH MY GIRL’s KCON:TACT 2020 SUMMER Performance
During a special stage at KCON:TACT 2020 SUMMER, YooA‘s styling included a jewel in the middle of her forehead that looked similar to a Bindi. In Hindu culture, a red dot in the middle of the forehead signifies a woman’s married status and wards off bad luck.
Like LOONA’s Vivi, Mimi wore a jeweled headpiece that resembled a matha patti.
6. NTX’s “Kiss the World” Concept Photos
Victory Company‘s rookie boy group NTX faced backlash for cultural appropriation shortly after their debut. These concept photos for “Kiss the World,” the title track on Full of Lovescapes, featured the members dressed in outfits to represent various countries, including Korea.
Fans, however, took issue with traditional cultural outfits from other countries being worn as “costumes.”
Victory Company later addressed these concerns in a statement.
We’ve carefully looked through your comments. First of all, we’re sorry for causing our fans discomfort.
Traditional clothes and fashion styles from worldwide nationalities are used simply to express a concept of the new music, ‘KISS THE WORLD’ of NTX.
Please understand the fact that neither offensive act nor intentional purpose were put in through the process.
Looking through your comments; now our company has realized that we should be more careful through the preparation process. We’ll be much more cautious about our future researching materials; so we can assure similar problems will not happen ever again. In addition, we’ll thoroughly prepare in advance for our ideas of NTX concepts at a future date.
We appreciate your concern. Thank you.
— Victory Company
7. WOODZ’s Headdress
Yuehua Entertainment found itself in hot water after WOODZ wore a traditional Plains Natives’ headdress in this concept photo.
The backlash drew mixed reactions from Korean and international fans, some of whom defended the styling choice as cultural appreciation.
Yuehua Entertainment later retracted the image and issued this statement: